I purchased two refill bottles one in freeze and shine and the other in super sculpt from ulta in st George ut. and I had noticed that they were unusually this and would not spray from the bottle correctly so I was telling my hair dresser about it (he has been practicing for over twenty years including teaching at a school) and he said I could bring them to him so he can see what i was talking about and right away he said that is not Paul Mitchell products they dont even smell close.